Last night I was at a departmental party to welcome the new students and our guest speaker/closet Discovery Institute apologist. As the night wore on, the party thinned out until it was just Matt Dunn, my advisor, and a post-doc from the Cognitive Science department (Karola). We got on the topic of whether psychological states can be ultimately reduced to neurons firing and such. We also were discussing whether computer programs *really* play chess or if they are simply manipulating symbols (the presupposition being that the former requires some "idea" of chess or understanding which is not present in the latter). Matt Dunn was pushing the line that Deep Blue does not play chess, and that there is something special about consciousness or being human. It was a light discussion and at 2 am after many beers, rigorous thought is supererogatory. Well, Karola begins to lay into Matt Dunn, calling him illogical and whatnot (imagine it in a German accent). Also, Matt Dunn made no pretension to being an expert on AI, philosophy of mind, or philosophy of psychology. I, ever the protective momma bear, jump in and say, reasonably I think, "Hold on, basically what Matt (Dunn) is suggesting is something along the lines of Searle's Chinese Room argument [a very famous argument in the philosophy of mind], and if he IS illogical (which he is not), he's in pretty good company being so." Well, Karola did not like this response to her polemical treatment of my friend's untutored position. Her reponse: "You are a bad philosopher. You think because Searle said it that it must be good. Searle has been refuted..." and it went on like that for a while. Of course I interjected that in fact I was not making some fallacious appeal to authority (Searle), but that I was sticking up for my friend and that I was merely pointing out that Matt Dunn's intuitions jibe with what some very smart people have said about the subject. Calling his intuitions "illogical" when he is not immersed in the literature (so he's unaware of the shortcomings of Searle's argument) is a bit unfair to him. Secondly, there's nothing wrong with having false intuitions. You have to start somewhere. I wish MY intuitions would stumble upon ingenious theses in the philosophy of mind ex nihilo.
So the lesson for this post:
Brian: good friend, bad philosopher
Justification: appeal to (self-appointed) authority, Karola
Saturday, September 08, 2007
Wednesday, September 05, 2007
Rawwwwwk! Raining Blood, from a Lacerated Sky!
Sunday, September 02, 2007
This weekend
This weekend's adventures involved a slip n' slide, an inflatable pool, and a troop of undergraduates.
My neighbors on either side got together to celebrate the first week of class at around 4 on Friday. The boys next door had spent the previous days filling a 600-gallon inflatable pool. They filled it as much as they could considering that they did not have the foresight to put it on level ground. Consequently, the pool was probably only 3/4 full. They encouraged me to jump in, but I chose to watch the beer pong match instead, which I also declined to participate in (though I had the night before).
The 5 girls who share the house with me set up a slip n' slide, extended with a large tarp, in the backyard. They did not have the foresight to remove all the sticks and rocks beneath the tarp and slip n' slide. Consequently, every girl scraped and bruised herself as she went down. Also, the tarp was not slick enough, so they lubricated it with baby oil and dishwashing liquid. This made them soapy, greasy messes when their battered bodies reached the end of the slip n' slide. They ecouraged me to join in, saying "come on brian, that slip n' slid has your name on it," but I chose to watch them repeatedly, masochistically, abuse themselves with each slide.
Later that night I went to a graduate student party, which ironically was busted by the cops and my former roommate and his roommates were fined a total of 200 dollars. I venture to say that if I phoned in a noise complaint where I live, the cops would just laugh at me. Keep those unruly grad students in line! The last thing they need is a break from work.
Early on Saturday I was walking Sebastian to the empty lot next door off his leash, but bound by the power of his e-collar. He minds well. But I saw the neighbors' dogs and told him to go say "hi." As his disappeared around the corner I heard screams and clamor. I did not know that the girls had a group of people in the porch, most of whom were sitting down playing a game of cards. Sebastian proved to be quite a disruption, destroying the card piles and accidentally scratching a girl. Consequently, I felt inclined to buy the kids a 12-pack of Corona or some other mediocre beer that they would think was fancy, but I decided not to when I heard a girl say "someone's fucking dog scratched the shit out of me." I still felt bad, but not inclined to buy them beer in order to smooth it over.
Tonight I went and saw Superbad, which was decent. Consequently, I enjoyed my movie experience other than the youngins next to me who would not quit talking. I declined to say something to them. I guess that puts me partially at fault. The Bourne Ultimatum was a better movie.
It is 2:02 and the neighbors are still going at it. At least there are no fights as there were Thursday night, which woke me up. Consequently, I did not get a good night of sleep, but it was entertaining to listen to the rumble.
I'm still enjoying a stint of productivity. I ran into my statistician/educational psychology friend at Matt's party and she gave me a good idea for the current section of my dissertation. One more name to add the the Acknowledgements section. 'Acknowledgements' is a long word for just 4 syllables.
And stuff...
My neighbors on either side got together to celebrate the first week of class at around 4 on Friday. The boys next door had spent the previous days filling a 600-gallon inflatable pool. They filled it as much as they could considering that they did not have the foresight to put it on level ground. Consequently, the pool was probably only 3/4 full. They encouraged me to jump in, but I chose to watch the beer pong match instead, which I also declined to participate in (though I had the night before).
The 5 girls who share the house with me set up a slip n' slide, extended with a large tarp, in the backyard. They did not have the foresight to remove all the sticks and rocks beneath the tarp and slip n' slide. Consequently, every girl scraped and bruised herself as she went down. Also, the tarp was not slick enough, so they lubricated it with baby oil and dishwashing liquid. This made them soapy, greasy messes when their battered bodies reached the end of the slip n' slide. They ecouraged me to join in, saying "come on brian, that slip n' slid has your name on it," but I chose to watch them repeatedly, masochistically, abuse themselves with each slide.
Later that night I went to a graduate student party, which ironically was busted by the cops and my former roommate and his roommates were fined a total of 200 dollars. I venture to say that if I phoned in a noise complaint where I live, the cops would just laugh at me. Keep those unruly grad students in line! The last thing they need is a break from work.
Early on Saturday I was walking Sebastian to the empty lot next door off his leash, but bound by the power of his e-collar. He minds well. But I saw the neighbors' dogs and told him to go say "hi." As his disappeared around the corner I heard screams and clamor. I did not know that the girls had a group of people in the porch, most of whom were sitting down playing a game of cards. Sebastian proved to be quite a disruption, destroying the card piles and accidentally scratching a girl. Consequently, I felt inclined to buy the kids a 12-pack of Corona or some other mediocre beer that they would think was fancy, but I decided not to when I heard a girl say "someone's fucking dog scratched the shit out of me." I still felt bad, but not inclined to buy them beer in order to smooth it over.
Tonight I went and saw Superbad, which was decent. Consequently, I enjoyed my movie experience other than the youngins next to me who would not quit talking. I declined to say something to them. I guess that puts me partially at fault. The Bourne Ultimatum was a better movie.
It is 2:02 and the neighbors are still going at it. At least there are no fights as there were Thursday night, which woke me up. Consequently, I did not get a good night of sleep, but it was entertaining to listen to the rumble.
I'm still enjoying a stint of productivity. I ran into my statistician/educational psychology friend at Matt's party and she gave me a good idea for the current section of my dissertation. One more name to add the the Acknowledgements section. 'Acknowledgements' is a long word for just 4 syllables.
And stuff...
Saturday, August 25, 2007
A Recent Conversation with Sebastian
b: Okay, Sebastian, what do you think about this proposition? I just spoke to Todd and apparently he had no troubles getting Gustav to Berlin. So I was thinking that perhaps you'd like to move to The Netherlands with me.
s: I hate you.
b: But really, buddy, as long as I could find a place in Amsterdam and a place in Tilburg where dogs are acceptable, you'd totally be able to come with me.
s: *rolling eyes* What make you think that I'd want to come with you?
b: Oh Basty, don't do me like that.
s: And, oh dear master, where will I go when you go to Russia? I suppose you'll just fly me all over the world waiting for some airline to lose me and send me to Cambodia. And then where would I be? All alone, unfamiliar with the language, unaccustomed to the cuisine. This conversation is just a bunch of b.s.
b: Phnom Penh, probably. But just think about it. I'd probably ship you back to the States before heading to Russia. Call your peeps and see if anyone would want you from May until mid-June. I'm still not sure if it is a possibility, depends on the housing situation. But we'll see.
s: I hate you. Go to hell. Bring back the big one you call 'Matt'; I liked him better, even if he was a bit loud and scary.
s: I hate you.
b: But really, buddy, as long as I could find a place in Amsterdam and a place in Tilburg where dogs are acceptable, you'd totally be able to come with me.
s: *rolling eyes* What make you think that I'd want to come with you?
b: Oh Basty, don't do me like that.
s: And, oh dear master, where will I go when you go to Russia? I suppose you'll just fly me all over the world waiting for some airline to lose me and send me to Cambodia. And then where would I be? All alone, unfamiliar with the language, unaccustomed to the cuisine. This conversation is just a bunch of b.s.
b: Phnom Penh, probably. But just think about it. I'd probably ship you back to the States before heading to Russia. Call your peeps and see if anyone would want you from May until mid-June. I'm still not sure if it is a possibility, depends on the housing situation. But we'll see.
s: I hate you. Go to hell. Bring back the big one you call 'Matt'; I liked him better, even if he was a bit loud and scary.
Thursday, August 23, 2007
Tales from the Shoebox
Where do I live? Is this Bloomington? This is no Bloomington I know. Immodestly dressed young ladies parading the streets, knuckle-dragging young men cat-calling. And this is all right outside my door on the street. There are more SUV's on my block than I recollect ever seeing when I lived on the south side of town. Basty looks at me disapprovingly as though I knew ahead of time that this would be our lot. He looks at me saying "I thought you said we'd never have to live in Panama City Beach again. Our daily existence is smack in the middle of spring break. Even one of your 5 coed neighbors has an airbrushed license plate on the front of her SUV." Yes, Basty, I know, and I'm sorry. But at least our internet is free. At least our water and gas seem to be free. "But, Brian, it is so noisy here and walks are so boring and ugly." Again, buddy, I know, but there is nothing I can do about it. "But Brian, what do you plan to do with me when you go to the Netherlands? Do you intend for me to stay here in the shoebox, listening to the rabble-rabble of voices outside the door, unable to freely run in a back yard to make poopies?" No Basty, I don't know yet what will become of you, but I am certain that it either involves becoming a menu item at Dragon Express or going on a long vacation from me. "Brian, do you see this look in my eyes? Look closely. This is the glare of disappointment." Basty, don't do that to me. If you want to eat tomorrow, you'll just go to (YOUR OWN) bed and sleep. We'll talk more later.
With a tinge of regret, a couple more pages of the dissertation, and a longing for Primanti Bros.,
B
With a tinge of regret, a couple more pages of the dissertation, and a longing for Primanti Bros.,
B
Monday, August 20, 2007
A Breath of Fresh Air
This delightful 3-page article is probably the best thing I've read since Cafe Rabelais' menu and winelist.
Tuesday, August 14, 2007
Summer Ends
I live in a shoebox. It is a comfotable shoebox which I have furnished with a chair, a small antique desk, a futon pad on the floor on which I sleep, and a table. My bedroom is more of a storage facility than a place to sleep: boxes are stacked agains the wall and floorspace is sparse. My place is just large enough for one, but a bit cramped for one and a dog. My apartment is an addition onto a house that is yet unoccupied; however, in a matter of days a gaggle of undergraduate girls will take up residence on the other side of my wall. I live next to the football stadium in what is known as the "undergraduate slums." Next door to me live several undergraduate boys and two unruly dogs. Their backyard is decorated with tiki torches and empty bud light cans. The only place to eat within walking distance is a mongolian barbeque where I once ate 4 or 5 years ago. I have not been back since because it made me ill. My office is 14 blocks south, making it too far to walk, but too close to drive to work. Though the neighborhood is quiet now, the kids are trickling in, and I expect mass convergence next weekend. The traffic is bad and broken bottles litter the foot of every other driveway, making walks with Sebastian precarious. And though I am a bit alienated this far north of where I used to live, and though I am struggling a bit with not having Matt around anymore to keep me from working and take me grocery shopping, I think being here will be good for my productivity. This year really needs to be about finishing up the dissertation and that it will be. Right now my sights are set on getting to Amsterdam and joining up with Tyson in St. Petersburg in May.
Tyson left today which for me marks the end of the summer. The summer began in May this year with my trip to Georgia and, appropriately I think, terminated in my friend's 5am departure this morning. Several days ago Todd left for Ohio and then Berlin (for 1, possibly 2 years). With the departures of Tyson and Todd, the end of NAPSS Hendrick's Nights, and leaving the nest at 928 S. Mitchell, I feel like this is a bittersweet new beginning. Strangely, I feel like a stranger in Bloomington. It is probably a good time to leave and I'm excited to take the next step.
From my shoebox, this is Brian. Over and out until our next installment.
Tyson left today which for me marks the end of the summer. The summer began in May this year with my trip to Georgia and, appropriately I think, terminated in my friend's 5am departure this morning. Several days ago Todd left for Ohio and then Berlin (for 1, possibly 2 years). With the departures of Tyson and Todd, the end of NAPSS Hendrick's Nights, and leaving the nest at 928 S. Mitchell, I feel like this is a bittersweet new beginning. Strangely, I feel like a stranger in Bloomington. It is probably a good time to leave and I'm excited to take the next step.
From my shoebox, this is Brian. Over and out until our next installment.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

